Independent consumer file. Not The General. Not Sentry.
Their claims line 1-800-280-1466THE PUBLIC RECORD · AUTO INSURANCE
The General sells nonstandard car insurance in a forest-green campaign about “a break.” State complaint math, repair-shop grades, and hundreds of public complaints describe something narrower: price shocks, quiet claim files, and bills after you cancel.
SIX PATTERNS
01 · Price
The brand promise is a break on the rate. The complaint that shows up over and over is that the break expires between the quote and the second invoice.
02 · Renewal
Nonstandard insurance is priced for risk. Customers say the price also moves when they cannot point to a new ticket, crash, or lapse.
03 · Getting out
People leave because of the price. A second cluster of complaints says the exit itself produces a balance, a collector, or a DMV lapse flag.
04 · Claims
This is the largest pile in the BBB complaint file: a claim number exists, and then the file goes quiet. It hits their own customers and the people their customers hit.
05 · Repair shops
CRASH Network asks repair shops, not policyholders, how carriers pay and behave. The General’s grade has been a D for years.
06 · Regulators
NAIC’s complaint index compares a company’s complaints with its size. 1.0 is the expected level. Publishers do not agree on a single figure for The General. They agree it is high.
FROM THE DOCKET
Posted on Trustpilot as an unprompted review. The writer says a short policy change moved a $97 quote to a $129 renewal after a $32 charge, that agents repeated “this is your offer, it can change anytime,” and that a switch to Progressive saved about $500 a year. The General replied on the thread.
Read it at the sourceFebruary 24, 2026 thread on r/Insurance. The original post was later deleted. Comments describe a claim closed the same day it was checked, three calls that reached only voicemail, and regulars telling the family to expect many more calls and to escalate past the assigned adjuster. That is forum advice, not a regulator finding.
Read it at the sourceBBB complaint dated December 29, 2025, answered. The filer says the DMV reported that The General did not send proof of insurance “in the correct, federally mandated way,” the license was suspended, and the refund did not cover the extra cost. BBB removed the state name.
Read it at the sourceBBB complaint dated December 28, 2025, answered, filed as a customer-service issue. The filer says the price tripled once a Social Security number was provided, and raises data-sharing and credit-reporting concerns. No state is printed.
Read it at the sourceDO NOT QUOTE THEM
The biggest books in the country are State Farm, Progressive, GEICO, and Allstate, then USAA, Farmers, and Liberty Mutual. If one declines you, quote the next one the same day. Never The General.
See better optionsIF YOU ARE STUCK
Auto insurance is state-regulated. Start with your department of insurance, then BBB, your attorney general, and the FTC if the advertising itself was the problem.
Build the complaint